In the face-off “Amazon Sumerian vs Google”, Amazon Sumerian is a superb choice for beginners and enterprises aiming to create AR/VR experiences, given its robust integration with AWS services and intuitive 3D creation tools. However, for developers prioritising data privacy and search functionality, Google’s technology ecosystem is a clear victor, also boasting remarkable mapping and Android capabilities.

Amazon Sumerian vs Google comparison

Key Differences Between Amazon Sumerian and Google

  • While Amazon Sumerian is built for creating AR/VR experiences, Google’s ecosystem encompasses diverse technologies including Search, Earth, Android OS, and more.
  • Sumerian offers AWS-integrated features for advanced scripting and dynamic scenarios, whereas Google thrives with its algorithm-based search results.
  • Google provides free search results crawling and indexing, while Sumerian charges based on total size of 3D assets and views per month post-trial.
  • Google’s Android led the mobile phone industry with a majority global market share, in contrast, Sumerian projects integration with ARCore on Android devices is still in progress.
  • Sumerian’s AWS IoT integration enables real-time sensor data integration with 3D objects, while Google uses user data for personalized search results, raising privacy concerns.
Comparison Amazon Sumerian Google Technologies
Platform Support Oculus, HTC Vive, iOS via WebVR; Android ARCore incoming Web-based, Android, iOS, Chrome OS
Key Features Creation of AR, VR, 3D applications; web-based editor; advanced scripting via 3D engine Google Earth, Google Maps, Chrome OS, Android OS, Google Analytics and Webmaster tools, personalized search
Integrated Services Amazon Polly, Amazon Lex, AWS Lambda, AWS IoT, Amazon DynamoDB Google Search, Google Maps, Google AdSense, Google Analytics, YouTube
Usage Training, visualizing financial modeling, customer relations Mapping, browsing, social networking, disaster relief
Cost Charges based on total size of 3D assets and views per month Most features free; Paid services available
Programming Knowledge Requirement No prior experience in VR, AR, 3D applications Varies with services
API/SDK Integration Integrated with multiple AWS services Integration with third party services with APIs
Machine Learning Capabilities Amazon Lex for AI; Polly for speech-to-text Ability to mashup with external databases, personalised feed by Discover

What Is Amazon Sumerian and Who’s It For?

Amazon Sumerian is a robust developer’s toolkit, designed to support the creation, building, and running of AR, VR, and 3D applications. Equipped with an intuitive web-based editor, it enables the importation of assets and scripting interactions for constructing 3D scenes. Despite being unavailable to new customers from May 18, 2022, its existing customers can access Sumerian data till February 21, 2023.

Crucially, it’s engineered for enterprises lacking in-house talents to tackle cutting-edge technology, providing an accessible platform for delivering multi-platform experiences. Often employed in training, visualizing financial modeling, and customer relations, it’s a favorite tool among startups and large enterprises.

Colorful illustration of a developer working on 3D scenes in an office environment

Pros of Amazon Sumerian

  • Supports multi-platform experiences
  • Built with an accessible web-based editor for 3D construction
  • Integrated with AWS services
  • Highly customisable Hosts

Cons of Amazon Sumerian

  • Unavailable to new customers from May 18, 2022
  • Supports only specific types of assets for import

What Is Google’s Technology and Who’s It For?

Google’s technology spectrum spans from the comprehensive Google Earth to the intuitive Chrome OS. Equipped with advanced analytics and webmaster tools, Google arms creators, developers, and every day users with insightful metrics to refine their approach. First introduced with Android OS and Chrome, Google’s technologies have evolved to provide more personalized and relevant experiences for users.

However, this data-driven approach raises valid privacy concerns. Despite this, it still leads the pack in delivering specialized tools like maps, shopping options, images, and videos. For businesses and creators, Google’s Search Engine and AdSense programs offer functionality and revenue opportunities that are hard to overlook.

Colorful image of a diverse group of people interacting with Google's suite of technology in a bustling city

Pros of Google’s Technology

  • Wide array of tools and services
  • Regularly updated and improved
  • Personalized user experiences
  • Powerful analytics and SEO tools

Cons of Google’s Technology

  • Privacy concerns due to data usage
  • Some services, like Google Buzz and Google+, discontinued

Amazon Sumerian or Google: Which is Your Tech Companion?

In the clash of digital titans, Amazon Sumerian and Google, each holds its ground with robust features. The choice depends on your realm of application.

AR/VR developers and Enterprises

For developers dipping into the AR/VR and 3D applications realm, Amazon Sumerian emerges as a competent ally. Its wide compatibility with various platforms such as Oculus, HTC Vive, iOS and soon-to-be-launched Android ARCore, coupled with user-friendly tools and resources, make it an appealing choice. Despite the cessation of new customer support, existing users still have accessibility till February 2023.

AR/VR developer designing immersive experiences with Amazon Sumerian

JavaScript Coders

Amazon Sumerian endears itself to JavaScript developers with its 3D engine allowing for advanced scripting. A bonus is the accessibility on GitHub for Sumerian Hosts. The integration with Amazon Lex, Polly, and AWS services make it a solid toolkit for coders.

JavaScript coder scripting interactions on Amazon Sumerian

Search engine optimizers and Bloggers

In the world of search engines and digital publishing, Google’s technology reigns supreme. Its robust algorithm identifying keyword context based on user intent, alongside specialized tools like maps, shopping options, and image searches, provide bloggers and SEO professionals with a competitive edge.

SEO professional optimizing website using Google's tools

Data-driven Professionals and Digital Marketers

Google’s technology proves itself indispensable to data-driven professionals and digital marketers with its introduction of Google Analytics, Webmaster Tools and its ownership of YouTube. However, privacy remains a concern with user data usage affecting personalized results.

Digital marketer analyzing data on Google Analytics

For AR/VR and 3D application development, Amazon Sumerian holds ground with its user-friendly toolkit and extensive AWS integration. However, Google’s comprehensive search engine and digital marketing prowess remain unmatched, despite privacy concerns.

Tiffany Brise

Content writer @ Aircada, patiently awaiting a consumer AR headset that doesn’t suck.

You may also like