If detailed 3D modelling is your focus, choose Metashape. It offers robust features, speed, and precision, but comes at a price. Conversely, Meshlab suits users who prioritize large mesh handling and open-source software, albeit with a complex interface and low user ratings.
Key Differences Between MeshLab and Metashape
- MeshLab is open-source, favoring large mesh handling, while Metashape excels in detailed 3D modelling.
- MeshLab received the Eurographics Software Award in 2017, while Metashape standout features include AI land-use classification, and cloud processing support.
- MeshLab’s interface is described as error-prone and complicated, whilst Metashape offers an updated UI with dark mode.
- The Professional version of Metashape is priced at $3499, whereas MeshLab is a free software.
| Comparison | MeshLab | Metashape by Agisoft |
|---|---|---|
| Processing Capabilities | Powerful 3D triangular mesh editing, cleaning, and rendering | Building detailed 2D or 3D models from images, depth maps |
| Usability | Described as error-prone and complicated | Updated UI, Workflow dropdown, Easy guidance |
| Price | Free. Open Source. | Standard Edition Costs $179 and Professional Edition Costs $3499 for a perpetual license. Educational discount available at $59 |
| Additional Features | New global registration plugin, Automatic github release | AI land-use classification, Cloud processing support, Virtual Desktop Compatibility, Auto mesh refinement, Single Camera Mode |
What Is MeshLab and Who’s It For?
An editor for large 3D triangular meshes, MeshLab is a key tool for the visualization and processing of unstructured 3D models. It serves individuals handling dense 3D data sets, including data scientists, researchers, and 3D design professionals.
The open-source software leans on the GPL VCG library for mesh processing tasks. With regular updates and the notable Eurographics Software Award in 2017, MeshLab underscores its role in the 3D landscape, despite criticisms of complexity and error proneness.
Pros of MeshLab
- Highly capable tool for editing, cleaning, and rendering large 3D triangular meshes.
- Constantly updated with new plugins and features.
- Recipient of the Eurographics Software Award in 2017.
Cons of MeshLab
- Often described as complicated and error-prone.
- Lower user ratings due to perceived usability issues.
- Inconsistent update cycles can lead to user uncertainty.
What Is Metashape by Agisoft and Who’s It For?
Metashape by Agisoft offers photogrammetry software for creating professional 2D or 3D models from images. Its use spans GIS, VFX production, indirect object measurement, and cultural heritage documentation.
Featuring enhanced compatibility and extended export options, Metashape is intended for professionals and enthusiasts needing precision in 3D modeling and image processing.
Pros of Metashape by Agisoft
- Offers creation of detailed 2D or 3D models from images.
- Compatibility with a variety of operating systems (Windows, Linux, MacOS).
- Enhanced processing speed compared to previous versions.
Cons of Metashape by Agisoft
- High accuracy data processing could be time-consuming (9 to 19+ hours).
- Professional edition is priced considerably higher than the standard edition.
- Markers are recommended for image alignment, indicating potential alignment challenges without them.
MeshLab vs Metashape: The Decisive Showdown
Following a comprehensive examination of two leading contenders in 3D processing and editing – MeshLab and Metashape, we now arrive at the determinative conclusion.
Tech Enthusiasts On a Budget
Given the monetary constraints, MeshLab holds the upper hand. Despite its complexity and error-prone nature, the open-source nature and extensive feature set could be a draw for tech enthusiasts who don’t mind a learning curve.
Professionals Needing Effiective Photogrammetry
For professionals requiring reliable photogrammetry tools for intricate tasks, Metashape is the clear winner. Its robust feature set such as AI land-use classification and cloud processing support in the Professional edition make it worthy of its price tag.
Educators and Students
For the educational realm where cost-effectiveness is crucial, Metashape shines with its steeply discounted educational licenses($59), and no limitations on photo numbers or GPU usage.
Web Developers and Animators
For those aspiring to create GPU-accelerated 3D animations in web browsers, MeshLab is the go-to, leveraging its integration with Three.js and its offerings in rendering captivating 3D graphics.
MeshLab and Metashape serve distinctive needs within the 3D processing spectrum. While MeshLab shines with its open-source nature and companionability with Three.js for web animations, Metashape, with its superior photogrammetry tools, caters effectively to professional and educational needs.
