If you aim for rich 3D experiences and can handle coding, Unreal Engine is your best bet. However, for 2D game development, GameMaker simplifies the process remarkably, making it ideal for beginners and full-time developers alike.

Differences of Unreal Engine and GameMaker

Key Differences Between Unreal Engine and GameMaker

  • Unreal Engine specializes in 3D graphics, while GameMaker is built for 2D game design.
  • Unreal Engine supports a wide range of platforms, including VR, whereas GameMaker primarily targets desktop games.
  • Unreal Engine features a royalties model for commercial use, whereas GameMaker offers tiered plans for different goals.
  • Unreal Engine’s programming language is C++, while GameMaker features a Code Editor supporting multiple languages.
Comparison Unreal Engine GameMaker
Target Audience Developers for 3D games, films, and television, including VR platforms. Recommended for developers familiar with C++. Beginners to full-time developers oriented towards 2D game development. Lauded for its simplicity and scalability.
Language Used C++ GameMaker Language (GML) and additionally supports Shader Languages (GLSL, HLSL etc.), JSON, and XML.
Platforms Wide range including desktop, mobile, console, and VR Desktop and major consoles
Recognized Work First game Unreal. The marketplace for purchasing and selling creations. Games published on the Epic Games Store exempt from royalty fees. Known for popular games like Undertale, Forager, Hyper Light Drifter, and Chicory: A Colorful Tale.
License Model Free for all, charges 5% of revenue for products that make more than $1 million and 5% for products more than $3000 per quarter. Free for schools and universities. Offers various tiers: Free, Creator, Indie, and Enterprise.
Planned Development Routinely updated Unreal Development Kit for creating iOS games and apps. Expected updates: new code editor, AI support, enhanced modding capabilities. Ongoing collaborations with OpenAI for AI integration. Mod.io extension development under way for easy addition of user-generated content.
Community Support Epic Games Store and Unreal Engine Marketplace for trade of resources. Offers 88% revenue share to content creators. Strong emphasis on community development and developer support.

What Is Unreal Engine and Who’s It For?

Unreal Engine (UE) is a suite of powerful 3D computer graphics game engines developed by Epic Games. It signifies a revolution in game development, making its debut in 1998 with the iconic game, Unreal. First used for PC first-person shooters, UE has since evolved into a choice engine used not just in various game genres but also in industries such as film and television. Written in C++, it flaunts an impressive platform versatility inclusive of desktop, mobile, console, and VR platforms. UE’s latest iteration, Unreal Engine 5 (UE5), made its grand entrance in April 2022.

Engineered for both veteran developers and newcomers, UE serves as a comprehensive tool enhancing creativity. It’s perfect for developers eager to tap into a world-class toolset for ratifying their game ideas. It’s also suitable for educational institutions thanks to its gratis offering to schools and universities.

Colorful scene of students and developers engrossed in a tech-focused workspace, each working on various Unreal Engine projects on their high-tech rigs

Pros of Unreal Engine

  • Supports a wide range of platforms
  • Accommodates varying levels of expertise, from beginners to pros
  • Packed with a feature-rich level editor, UnrealEd
  • Unreal Engine Marketplace fosters a creative community
  • Generous revenue sharing model for content creators
  • Free for educational institutions

Cons of Unreal Engine

  • Could be demanding for beginners
  • Royalty fee for commercial use
  • Deep learning curve with C++

What Is GameMaker and Who’s It For?

GameMaker is a distinguished 2D game engine celebrated for its commitment to simplicity and accessibility. With over 17 years of development from its humble origins as Animo, GameMaker has evolved into a robust platform heralded for its scalability and toolset. Ideal for rookies and seasoned developers alike, GameMaker’s broad appeal is evident in notable games that include Undertale, Forager, and Chicory: A Colorful Tale.

If you’re an aspiring game developer seeking an intuitive platform that doesn’t compromise on depth, GameMaker should be high on your list. It caters to varying development needs with a tiered offering: Free, Creator, Indie, and Enterprise levels. These options provide flexible routes for hobby projects, professional commercial releases, and everything in between.

Colorful image of a diverse group of developers engaging in a game jam, heads bent over their computers in deep concentration, each creating unique 2D games on GameMaker

Pros of GameMaker

  • Highly accessible for beginners
  • Diverse range of pricing tiers for different needs
  • Scalable from simple to complex projects
  • Promotes user-generated content with mod.io extension
  • Continuously innovating with feature updates and enhancements

Cons of GameMaker

  • Limited to 2D game development
  • Some advanced features confined to higher pricing tiers

The Final Rumble: Unreal Engine vs GameMaker

The Verdict section of the Unreal Engine vs GameMaker faceoff will light your path. Buckle up as we saddle up this final charge.

The Virtuoso Coders

For the maestros weaving intricate code, Unreal Engine undeniably triumphs. An opportunity to channel the raw power of C++, a royalty model that’s generous, and a vibrant marketplace—Unreal Engine hails as your divine blueprint. The Unreal Development Kit, with iOS support, ushers in an aggressive versatility edge.

command Trench-coated coder, engrossed in abstract lines of C++ code, crafting a new reality with Unreal Engine, in a neon-lit workspace

The 2D Connoisseurs

If your gaming vision reels in the 2D realm, gambol with GameMaker. Celebrated by both greenhorns and veterans, its simplicity is its strongest suit. Scalable, user-friendly, and replete with tools for an equivocal game-making journey, GameMaker is 2D paradise. Undertale, Forager, and Chicory: A Colorful Tale attest to this.

an indie developer, bringing neon-filled, 2D arcade dreams to life with GameMaker, surrounded by vintage gaming posters

The Education Pioneers

In the hallowed halls of academia, Unreal Engine steals the show, offering its superpowers for free to Schools and Universities. Craft a curriculum that’s dynamic, hand-on, and directly applicable to the modern industry.

students and teacher, brainstorming over a holographic display of Unreal Engine project, in a hi-tech digital classroom

The Budget Considerants

Wallet-friendly decision? Look no further than GameMaker. Its tiered offer structure ensures you pay for what you use. From aspiring developers to hardened studios, GameMaker fills every purse.

desk littered with coffee cups and crumpled sketches, indie developer counting coins, contemplating GameMaker's tier options

In conclusion, if you seek robust 3D capabilities, raw coding power, and liberal application across platforms, Unreal Engine is king. However, for 2D enthusiasts, upstarts, and value seekers, GameMaker’s charm is irresistible. The final ax falls on your unique needs.

Tiffany Brise

Content writer @ Aircada, patiently awaiting a consumer AR headset that doesn’t suck.

You may also like