Unraveling the Mystery: Unreal Engine vs GameSalad

For developers venturing into complex 3D game programming, Unreal Engine, with its advanced graphics and comprehensive feature set stands out. However, newcomers to game creation or those seeking a simpler development environment may find GameSalad‘s drag-and-drop engine a better fit.

Key Differences Between Unreal Engine and GameSalad

• Unreal Engine is a powerful, professional-grade tool designed for advanced 3D game development, whereas GameSalad is a beginner-friendly platform that uses drag-and-drop coding.
• Unreal Engine uses C++ for game development, GameSalad doesn’t require coding knowledge, relying on a graphical user interface.
• GameSalad promotes STEAM learning and has partnered with educators, while Unreal Engine is primarily commercial, waiving its royalty model only for games published on the Epic Games Store.
• Unreal Engine is a potent tool for PC and console game creation, GameSalad targets primarily mobile and web-based platforms.
• Unreal Engine charges a percentage of revenues over USD $1 million, GameSalad offers a free basic platform with additional features through a Pro package.

Comparison	Unreal Engine	GameSalad
Development Language	C++	Graphical UI for rules and behaviors
Platform Support	Desktop, mobile, console, VR platforms	Android, iOS, Windows, Amazon Marketplace
Cost Model	Free up to USD 1 million revenue, 5% royalties beyond that	Free, with pro features for purchase
Educational Use	Free for schools and universities	Discounts for students, educators
Game Testing	Unsupported	On Apple devices
Community Support	Unreal Engine Marketplace, tutorials	Extensive GameSalad tutorials, GameSalad Academy
Publishing	Various platforms including Epic Games Store	App Store, cross-platform publishing
Special Features	Basic project templates, level editor, support for creating iOS games	Drag-and-drop coding platform, in-app previewer for testing, integrated physics

What Is Unreal Engine and Who’s It For?

Unreal Engine, a product of Epic Games, is a cutting-edge 3D computer graphics game engine. The tool, first introduced in 1998, has seen multiple versions, each advancing in supporting diverse game genres and platforms such as PC, mobile, consoles, and VR. The latest version, Unreal Engine 5, brings a slew of enhancements, demonstrating Epic’s commitment to pushing gaming technology’s boundaries. It’s a tool designed for game developers, modders, and anyone with an interest in creating interactive digital experiences, from large-scale productions to indie developers.

Pros of Unreal Engine

• Supports a wide range of platforms
• Armed with advanced features and a robust level editor
• 5% royalty model waived for games published on the Epic Games Store
• 88% revenue share to marketplace content creators and Unreal Engine free for education

Cons of Unreal Engine

• Technology learning curve
• 5% of revenues charged over USD 1 million for commercial use
• Development relied heavily on C++ programming language

What Is GameSalad and Who’s It For?

GameSalad is a game creation engine that simplifies the process of video game development through a user-friendly drag-and-drop interface. Known for its cross-platform capabilities, it enables users to develop and test games for iPhone, iPad, Android, and HTML5. The tool aims not just at professional developers but also educators and students, encouraging STEAM learning through game creation. With a free version available, GameSalad is a great starting point for beginners in game development and education.

Pros of GameSalad

• Drag-and-drop coding platform for easy game development
• Supports multiple platforms
• Promotes STEAM learning
• Discounts for students, educators, and US Military

Cons of GameSalad

• Limited advanced features compared to other platforms
• Free members not supported since 2015
• Half of staff laid off in 2012 raising questions about stability

Unreal Engine vs GameSalad: Which One Triumphs?

After an in-depth comparison, it’s time to provide a decisive verdict. Let’s dissect how each technology fairs for different audience segments.

Developers and Game Makers

For seasoned developers and game makers, Unreal Engine is the ideal choice. Its flexibility, broad platform support, and robust C++ programming environment allow for creating intricate, high-quality games. Features like real-time constructive solid geometry operations and mod-friendly engine make it a valuable asset.

AR/VR Creators

Again, Unreal Engine shines brighter. Its extensive VR support and acquired features from companies like Quixel allow creators to design immersive, realistic AR/VR experiences. Its real-time rendering capability sets it apart, making it the preferred choice for AR/VR developers.

Novice Game Designers and Tech Enthusiasts

For those starting out or practicing on a simpler project, GameSalad will suffice. Its drag-and-drop game creation engine and simple behavioral libraries make it suitable for beginners, enabling them to create iPhone, iPad, Android, and HTML5 games.

Educational Institutes

GameSalad, with its educational discounts, STEAM learning promotion, and curriculum aligned with ISTE & state CS standards, is an excellent choice for institutions teaching computer science concepts, logic-based thinking, and problem-solving through game design.

If you’re a seasoned developer or AR/VR creator who demands depth, choose Unreal Engine. For newcomers or education providers, the user-friendly GameSalad may suit better.